Which Fish Is For Me?

Three questions against the site's own species guides — tank size, experience and what you want to watch. It narrows the list; the care guide makes the decision.

Your matches

Enter your tank size — your top three matches appear here, with why each one fits.

Why use this calculator?

  • Answer three questions — tank size, experience and what you want to watch — and get your top three matches from the site's own ten species guides.
  • Beginners only see beginner species, and nothing that needs a bigger tank than yours makes the list.
  • Every match links to its care guide — the quiz narrows the list; the care guide makes the decision.
  • Get a match for what you actually want — a peaceful community, one showpiece fish, active schooling fish, or a shrimp colony.

Browse all ten species with filters in the Species Finder, or check a combination in the Compatibility Checker. · Back to Stocking & Fish Care

Answer three questions and get your top matches from the site's own species guides. Everything runs in your browser; nothing is saved.

How it works

The quiz scores the site's ten species against your three answers. Two hard filters run first, then a score per wish — and only species with a score above 0 make the list. The top three, highest score first, are your matches.

Hard filter 1 — tank size. A species is out if its minimum tank is bigger than yours. A 10-gallon tank rules out Goldfish, Bolivian Ram and Black Ruby Barb (all min 20 gal) and Panda Cory (min 15 gal) before scoring starts.

Hard filter 2 — experience. Beginners only see beginner-difficulty species. The three intermediate species — Bolivian Ram, Chili Rasbora and Celestial Pearl Danio — never appear for a beginner, whatever the tank size. Experienced keepers see all ten, subject to the tank filter.

Scoring, per wish. For "a peaceful community": a schooling fish scores 2, a shrimp scores 1, any other peaceful fish scores 1, and a solitary fish is out. For "one showpiece fish": a solitary fish scores 3, a non-schooling fish scores 2, a schooling fish scores 0 — and 0 means it does not make the list. For "active schooling fish": a schooling fish scores 2, anything else scores 0, and a solitary fish is out. For "a shrimp colony": a shrimp scores 5, any other peaceful fish scores 1, and a solitary fish is out.

Ties. Species with equal scores keep the order of the species guides — the first three in that order win. A tie at the cut-off is decided by guide order, not by a further test.

Worked example

20 gallons, beginner, "a peaceful community".

Inputs

Tank: 20 gal. Experience: beginner. Wish: a peaceful community. Ten species in the guides.

Formula

Hard filters first (min tank ≤ 20 gal; beginner difficulty only), then score: schooling fish 2, shrimp 1, other peaceful fish 1, solitary out. Top three by score.

Calculation

Nothing is out on tank size at 20 gal. Beginners lose the three intermediate species (Bolivian Ram, Chili Rasbora, Celestial Pearl Danio). Betta is out (solitary). Cherry Shrimp scores 1, Goldfish scores 1, Ember Tetra scores 2, Harlequin Rasbora scores 2, Panda Cory scores 2, Black Ruby Barb scores 2. Four species tie at 2; guide order takes the first three.

Result

Ember Tetra, Harlequin Rasbora and Panda Cory — all "peaceful schooling fish — keep 6+". Black Ruby Barb also scored 2 but is fourth in guide order, so it misses the cut.

A second check shows the showpiece logic. 5 gallons, beginner, "one showpiece fish": the tank filter leaves only Betta, Cherry Shrimp and Chili Rasbora (every other species needs 10 gallons or more), then the beginner filter removes Chili Rasbora (intermediate). Betta scores 3 (solitary), Cherry Shrimp scores 2 (works as a centrepiece without a school). The result is Betta, then Cherry Shrimp.

How to read your results

The verdict word is "Your top matches". Under it, the pair line repeats your three answers — tank size, experience and wish — so you can see what the matches were scored against. The stat grid shows one stat per match: the species name, with its minimum tank and temperature range underneath.

Below the stats, each match gets a row saying why it fits — "peaceful schooling fish — keep 6+", or "a single-feature fish — keep it alone" — with a link to its care guide. The note row at the bottom is the limit of the quiz: three answers cannot know your water, your filter or your patience, so check the match against the Stocking Calculator and the care guide before you commit.

If the card says "No match for that tank", nothing in the guides fits — even a betta needs 5 gallons, and schooling fish need 10+. A bigger tank opens up the whole list. If it says "Enter your tank size", the tank field is empty or not a number.

Common mistakes

  • Treating the quiz as the decision. It narrows the list; the care guide makes the decision — temperature, pH, school size and temperament all need a read before you buy.
  • Forgetting school size. A top match that is a schooling fish needs its school — 6+ for Ember Tetra, Harlequin Rasbora, Panda Cory, Black Ruby Barb and Celestial Pearl Danio, 8+ for Chili Rasbora. One schooling fish alone is a stressed fish.
  • Picking a showpiece betta for a community tank. The quiz scores a betta 3 for "one showpiece fish" because it is solitary — keep it alone.
  • Mixing shrimp with a betta because both appeared as matches. The quiz scores species one at a time; it never checks a pair. Check any combination in the Compatibility Checker — most bettas hunt dwarf shrimp.
  • Buying before cycling. The tank must be cycled first — dose 2–4 ppm ammonia and finish only when ammonia and nitrite both read 0 within 24 hours, usually 4–8 weeks. Shrimp are less forgiving of ammonia and nitrite than fish.
  • Reading "fits in 5 gallons" as "thrives in 5 gallons". A betta's minimum is 5 gallons, but 10+ is meaningfully better; the same applies to chili rasboras.

Species the quiz scores

The ten species in our care guides, with the numbers the hard filters use.

SpeciesMin tankDifficultyTemperamentSchoolTemperaturepH
Betta5 galBeginnerSolitary—76–82°F6.5–7.5
Black Ruby Barb20 galBeginnerPeaceful6+72–76°F6.0–7.0
Bolivian Ram20 galIntermediatePeaceful—74–78°F6.0–7.5
Celestial Pearl Danio10 galIntermediatePeaceful6+72–76°F6.5–7.5
Cherry Shrimp5 galBeginnerPeaceful—65–78°F6.5–7.5
Chili Rasbora5 galIntermediatePeaceful8+74–78°F5.0–7.0
Ember Tetra10 galBeginnerPeaceful6+72–78°F6.0–7.0
Goldfish (Fancy)20 galBeginnerPeaceful—65–75°F7.0–8.4
Harlequin Rasbora10 galBeginnerPeaceful6+73–77°F6.0–7.0
Panda Cory15 galBeginnerPeaceful6+68–74°F6.0–7.0

— means no school minimum applies. These are our recommendations — the ranges we publish in our care guides — not the full documented range.

FAQ

Why did Black Ruby Barb miss the cut in the worked example?

It scored 2, the same as Ember Tetra, Harlequin Rasbora and Panda Cory. Ties keep the order of the species guides, and Black Ruby Barb is fourth of the four in that order — the quiz only shows the top three.

Why does the quiz never suggest a betta for a community?

Because solitary fish are excluded from the community wish entirely. A betta scores 3 for "one showpiece fish" and nothing for a community — males are solitary and territorial.

Why does "active schooling fish" only ever return schooling fish?

Because anything that is not a schooling fish scores 0 for that wish, and 0 does not make the list. In a 10-gallon beginner tank that leaves Ember Tetra and Harlequin Rasbora.

Can the quiz suggest a shrimp colony in a 5-gallon tank?

Yes — Cherry Shrimp scores 5 for "a shrimp colony" and its minimum is 5 gallons. In a 5-gallon beginner tank it is the only match with a score above 0 for that wish.

What if my tank is under 5 gallons?

There is no match. Even a betta needs 5 gallons, and schooling fish need 10+. A bigger tank opens up the whole list.

Does the quiz check my water?

No — three answers cannot know your water, your filter or your patience. Check your water with the Water Parameter Checker and read the care guide for each match before you buy.

Can I trust the quiz to pick tankmates that get along?

No — it scores species one at a time and never checks a pair. Use the Compatibility Checker for any combination, especially with shrimp or a betta.

Sources

  1. TheCycledTank species database — the care-guide numbers this quiz scores on (Our recommendation).
  2. TheCycledTank care guides — Betta (betta-fish-care-guide), Cherry Shrimp (cherry-shrimp-care-guide), Goldfish (Fancy) (goldfish-care-guide), Ember Tetra (ember-tetra-care-guide), Harlequin Rasbora (harlequin-rasbora-care-guide), Bolivian Ram (bolivian-ram-care-guide), Chili Rasbora (chili-rasbora-care-guide), Panda Cory (panda-cory-care-guide), Black Ruby Barb (black-ruby-barb-care-guide), Celestial Pearl Danio (celestial-pearl-danio-care-guide) (Our care guides).
  3. Seriously Fish — Betta splendens species profile (Species profile). seriouslyfish.com/species/betta-splendens/
  4. ShrimpGuide — Cherry shrimp care guide, Neocaridina davidi (Hobby practice). shrimpguide.com/cherry-shrimp-care/

Related tools