Pick your tank size and the marine species you want, and get a verdict from published care numbers — minimum tank size, school sizes, shared temperature and pH, temperament and reef safety. No inch-per-gallon math. Everything runs in your browser; nothing is saved.
How it works
The checker runs five checks on the stocking and gives one of three verdicts. The numbers come from the species table below — published care numbers, with the larger (more conservative) minimum used where sources disagree.
Minimum tank. Every species needs its own minimum tank size. Your tank must meet the largest minimum in the stocking — a yellow tang in a 20-gallon tank fails here, whatever else matches.
School sizes. Schooling fish need their school. Green chromis need 6 or more; fewer than that stresses the fish, and the checker says how many to add.
Shared temperature and pH. For each, the shared range is [the higher of the minimums, the lower of the maximums]. All twelve species share the marine band — temperature 72–82°F, pH 8.1–8.4 — because per-species temperature ranges were not consistently documented across sources, and narrower bands are not invented. A shared range narrower than 2°F (temperature) or 0.2 (pH) is flagged as hard to hold stable.
Temperament and reef safety. An aggressive fish with peaceful tankmates is a caution — add it last, and only with plenty of rockwork and hiding places. "Reef safe with caution" means it may eat small shrimp and tiny snails, and it can harass peaceful tankmates.
The verdicts. "Looks compatible" means no blocks and no cautions. "Risky — fix the warnings" means nothing here is an instant disaster, but the flagged items stress fish over time. "Won't work as listed" means at least one blocking problem — fix those first, then re-check.
What it does not check. Footprint — a long tank suits a tang far better than a tall one of the same gallons. Bioload and filtration. Individual temperament, quarantine, and whether the tank is cycled. Marine tanks still need RO/DI water, stable salinity (1.024–1.026) and a cycled tank before any fish go in.
Worked example
A 20-gallon tank with a pair of ocellaris clownfish and one firefish.
20 gal. Ocellaris Clownfish ×2 (min 20 gal, peaceful, reef safe). Firefish ×1 (min 20 gal, peaceful, reef safe).
Tank need = largest minimum. Shared range = [max of minimums, min of maximums] for temperature and pH. Schools checked against their minimums.
Tank need = max(20, 20) = 20 gal; your 20 gal passes. Shared temp = 72–82°F, 10°F wide. Shared pH = 8.1–8.4, 0.3 wide. No school minimums breached. Both peaceful, both reef safe.
"Looks compatible" — 2× Ocellaris Clownfish + 1× Firefish in 20 gal. Firefish are jumpers, so a tight lid or mesh cover is still part of keeping them.
The opposite cases show what blocks and cautions look like. A yellow tang in the same 20-gallon tank: "Won't work as listed" — it needs at least 100 gallons. And 3 green chromis in a 30-gallon tank: "Risky — fix the warnings" — chromis need a school of 6 or more, so raise them to at least 6.
How to read your results
The verdict word is the headline, and the stocking line under it names what you picked. The stat grid shows the three numbers that decide the tank: shared temperature, shared pH, and your tank against the largest minimum the stocking needs.
Below the stats, the checks are grouped. "Needs action" is a block — fix it before buying. "Caution" is a risk — possible with more space, hiding places, and close watching. "OK" means that check passed. If there are fixes, they are listed under "How to fix it".
What to do next depends on the verdict. "Looks compatible": still check the notes — firefish need a lid, tangs need swimming room, shrimp are on the menu for aggressive wrasses. "Risky": work through the caution rows before you buy. "Won't work as listed": change one species, or change the tank.
Common mistakes
- Putting a tang in a nano tank. A yellow tang needs 100 gallons and a blue tang 180 — gallons alone do not describe the swimming room they need.
- Using inch-per-gallon. Waste scales with mass, not length, and tangs need room that gallons do not describe — this checker does not use it.
- Keeping schooling fish in too-small groups. Three chromis in a 30-gallon tank is a caution, not a pass — they need 6 or more.
- Forgetting footprint. A 6 ft tank suits a blue tang far better than a tall tank of the same volume.
- Adding the aggressive fish first. A six-line wrasse with peaceful tankmates ends in chasing and nipped fins — add it last, with plenty of rockwork.
- Assuming "reef safe" means shrimp-safe. "Reef safe with caution" means it may eat small shrimp and tiny snails — check the tankmates, not just the gallons.
- Skipping the lid. Firefish are jumpers — a tight lid or mesh cover is part of keeping them, whatever the stocking verdict says.
- Stocking an uncycled tank. The verdict says nothing about cycling — the tank must be cycled, with RO/DI water and stable salinity, before any fish go in.
Species in this checker
The twelve marine species this checker runs on — minimum tank size, school minimum, temperature, pH, temperament, reef safety and adult size, from the published care references in Sources. Where sources disagreed on a minimum, the larger (more conservative) value is used.
| Species | Min tank | School | Temp | pH | Temperament | Reef safe | Size |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Banggai Cardinalfish | 30 gal | — | 72–82°F | 8.1–8.4 | Peaceful | Yes | 3 in |
| Blue Tang (Regal Tang) | 180 gal | — | 72–82°F | 8.1–8.4 | Semi-aggressive | Yes | 8–12 in |
| Firefish | 20 gal | — | 72–82°F | 8.1–8.4 | Peaceful | Yes | 3 in |
| Green Chromis | 30 gal | 6+ | 72–82°F | 8.1–8.4 | Peaceful | Yes | 3 in |
| Neon Goby | 10 gal | — | 72–82°F | 8.1–8.4 | Peaceful | Yes | 2 in |
| Ocellaris Clownfish | 20 gal | — | 72–82°F | 8.1–8.4 | Peaceful | Yes | 3 in |
| Pajama Cardinalfish | 30 gal | — | 72–82°F | 8.1–8.4 | Peaceful | Yes | 3.5 in |
| Royal Gramma | 30 gal | — | 72–82°F | 8.1–8.4 | Peaceful | Yes | 3 in |
| Six-Line Wrasse | 30 gal | — | 72–82°F | 8.1–8.4 | Aggressive | With caution | 3 in |
| Skunk Cleaner Shrimp | 20 gal | — | 72–82°F | 8.1–8.4 | Peaceful | Yes | 2 in |
| Yellow Tang | 100 gal | — | 72–82°F | 8.1–8.4 | Semi-aggressive | Yes | 8 in |
| Yellow Watchman Goby | 20 gal | — | 72–82°F | 8.1–8.4 | Peaceful | Yes | 3–4 in |
— means no school minimum for that species. Every species shares the same 72–82°F and pH 8.1–8.4 band: per-species temperature ranges were not consistently documented across sources, so narrower bands are not invented — the shared band is the site's marine water band, not a per-species claim.
FAQ
Why no inch-per-gallon?
That rule measures length while waste scales with mass, and it ignores species waste differences, filtration, territory and schooling. This checker tests what actually decides stocking: minimum tank size, school sizes, shared temperature and pH, temperament and reef safety.
Why do all species share the same temperature and pH?
Per-species temperature ranges were not consistently documented across the care references, so the checker uses the site's marine band — 72–82°F, pH 8.1–8.4 — for all twelve species rather than inventing narrower bands. The minimum tank sizes, school minimums and temperaments are per-species; the water band is not.
Can I keep a yellow tang in a 75-gallon tank?
No — it needs at least 100 gallons, and a blue tang needs 180 gallons and a 6 ft tank. Tangs need open swimming room, not just gallons, and a long tank suits them far better than a tall one of the same volume.
What does "reef safe with caution" mean?
It may eat small shrimp and tiny snails, and it can harass peaceful tankmates. In this checker that is the six-line wrasse — reef safe, but aggressive, and cleaner shrimp are on the menu for aggressive wrasses and larger predators.
Does "Looks compatible" guarantee the fish will get along?
No. The checker does not test individual temperament, and an aggressive fish added first can still claim the tank. Add assertive fish last, give the tank plenty of rockwork and hiding places, and watch new arrivals for the first weeks.
What do I need before any fish go in?
A cycled tank, RO/DI water, and stable salinity at 1.024–1.026. The verdict says nothing about cycling or water quality — stocking is only one part of a marine tank, and the water itself must be ready first.
Sources
- Hobby practice — LiveAquaria minimum tank sizes (via hydrohabitats.com and reptileknowledge.com). Blue tang 180 gal and 6 ft; yellow tang 100 gal. Used for the two tang minimums.
- Hobby practice — saltwateraquariumblog.com. Ocellaris clownfish 3 in, 10–20 gal; royal gramma 3 in, 10–30 gal; firefish 3.5 in, 20 gal. Used for those three species' minimums.
- Hobby practice — Coralife. Ocellaris clownfish 10 gal, firefish 10 gal, royal gramma 30 gal. Used as the cross-check that set the conservative minimums above (20 gal clownfish, 20 gal firefish, 30 gal gramma).
- Hobby practice — MyReefLog stocking calculator. Banggai cardinalfish 3 in, 30 gal; blue-green chromis 3.5 in, 30 gal; pajama cardinalfish 3.5 in, 30 gal; six-line wrasse 3.5 in, 30 gal, aggressive. Used for those four species.
- Hobby practice — aquariumsforbeginners.com, tankbud.com, fantaseaaquariums.com, summitcitycoral.com. Chromis 3 in, 20–30 gal; six-line wrasse 3 in, 30 gal; banggai cardinalfish 3 in, 30 gal; royal gramma 3 in, 30 gal; firefish 3 in, 20 gal; skunk cleaner shrimp 2.4 in, 20 gal, 73–81°F, pH 8.1–8.4; yellow watchman goby 3.5 in, 20 gal; neon goby 2 in, 10 gal. Used for the remaining minimums and the shrimp and goby figures.
- Our data — TheCycledTank saltwater stocking dataset. The twelve-species table above, compiled from the sources listed here. Where sources disagreed on a minimum tank size, the larger (more conservative) value is used; all species share the marine band 72–82°F, pH 8.1–8.4 because per-species ranges were not consistently documented.
The source names above are recorded in the tool's data file without full URLs, so no links are given here — the names are the trail on file.