Symptom Explorer

This is information, not a diagnosis: it lists what a symptom is often linked to and what to check first. Symptoms overlap, and only a vet can confirm what is actually wrong.

What it often means

Pick the closest match — what it is often linked to, and what to check first, appear here.

Why use this calculator?

  • Pick what you see from eight common signs — white spots, gasping, clamped fins, bloating, fin rot, flashing, not eating or red gills — and see what each is often linked to.
  • Every entry says what to check first, and the first check is almost always the water: ammonia and nitrite must read 0.
  • Information, not a diagnosis: symptoms overlap, and only a vet can confirm what is actually wrong.
  • Serious signs point to a vet promptly — bloating with pinecone scales, for example, is rarely fixable with water changes alone.

The first check is almost always the water — run the Water Parameter Checker. Ammonia and nitrite must read 0; if either is above 0, a water change comes before any other step. · Back to Stocking & Fish Care

Pick what you see and get what it is often linked to and what to check first. Information, not a diagnosis. Everything runs in your browser; nothing is saved.

How it works

The explorer holds eight common signs. Pick the one closest to what your fish is doing and you get three things: what it looks like, what it is often linked to, and what to check first. One symptom at a time gives the clearest answer — two signs at once usually share one cause, so start with the worst one.

What it is often linked to. Every entry says "often linked to", never "caused by". Symptoms overlap: clamped fins can mean poor water, wrong temperature, bullying or a bare tank, and the same white spots can come from more than one problem. The explorer describes the usual links; it does not pick one for you.

What to check first. The first check is almost always the water: ammonia must read 0, nitrite must read 0, nitrate under 40 ppm. Those three numbers are the site's water targets, and they sit at the top of every result. If ammonia or nitrite reads above 0, a water change comes before any other step.

What it never does. It never prescribes a treatment and never names a dose. Anything serious points to a vet — bloating with pinecone scales, for example, is rarely fixable with water changes alone, and gill problems are hard to judge by eye. Do not medicate the main tank on a guess.

Worked example

Gasping at the surface.

Inputs

Symptom: gasping at the surface — fish hanging at the top, gulping air. No water test yet.

Formula

Match the sign to its entry: what it looks like, what it is often linked to, what to check first — against the water targets ammonia 0, nitrite 0, nitrate under 40 ppm.

Calculation

Gasping is often linked to low oxygen or ammonia/nitrite in the water — both are urgent. Test ammonia and nitrite now. If either reads above 0, do a 30–50% water change and increase surface agitation (raise the filter outlet, add an air stone).

Result

"Gasping at the surface" — check-first step: test ammonia and nitrite now; above 0 means a 30–50% water change immediately. Do not wait to see if it passes.

A second check shows the vet end of the scale. Bloating with pinecone scales — swollen belly, scales sticking out like a pinecone — is often linked to dropsy, fluid building up when organs fail. The check-first step is a vet, promptly: it is rarely fixable with water changes alone. Move the fish to a quarantine tank, keep the water clean, and do not medicate the main tank on a guess.

How to read your results

The verdict word is the sign you picked — "Gasping at the surface", for example — and the line under it says what it looks like. The stat grid shows the three water numbers to test first: ammonia 0 ppm, nitrite 0 ppm, nitrate under 40 ppm.

Below the stats, three labelled rows follow. "Often linked to" is the usual association — a starting point, not a diagnosis. "Check first" is the action to take before anything else, usually a water test and a water change. "Caution" is the limit of the tool: symptoms overlap and only a vet (or a lab test) can confirm what is actually wrong. If a fish is gasping, bloated or getting worse fast, ask a vet instead of waiting.

What to do next depends on the water test. Clean water (ammonia 0, nitrite 0) with a fish that is still clamped or hiding usually means stress, bullying or a bare tank — watch, add cover, give a new fish a day to settle. Dirty water means water changes first, whatever the symptom.

Common mistakes

  • Medicating the main tank on a guess. A wrong medication stresses every fish and can crash the filter bacteria — confirm the water first, and the diagnosis second.
  • Waiting on gasping. Gasping at the surface with ammonia or nitrite above 0 is an emergency: a 30–50% water change now, not tomorrow.
  • Treating one symptom as one disease. Clamped fins, not eating and flashing all overlap — test the water and the temperature before naming a cause.
  • Assuming a new fish that skips a day is sick. A new fish skipping a day is normal; a fish that has eaten for weeks and stops is worth watching closely.
  • Missing the bully. Clamped fins and hiding often mean one tankmate doing the chasing — watch the tank before treating the fish.
  • Reaching for chemicals when clean water would do. Fin rot usually follows ammonia or nitrite — a 25–30% water change and removing the nipper often stops it without medication.
  • Skipping quarantine for a bloated fish. A fish with pinecone scales goes to a quarantine tank and a vet — the main tank is not the place to experiment.

Symptoms at a glance

All eight signs, what each is often linked to, and what to check first.

SymptomWhat it looks likeOften linked toCheck first
White spots like salt grainsTiny white dots on fins and bodyIch, a parasite — usually introduced with a new fish or plantTest ammonia and nitrite first; confirm the water is clean and the temperature is steady before medicating
Gasping at the surfaceFish hanging at the top, gulping airLow oxygen or ammonia/nitrite in the water — both are urgentTest ammonia and nitrite NOW — above 0 means a 30–50% water change and more surface agitation
Clamped fins / hidingFins held tight to the body, fish hiding all dayStress — poor water, wrong temperature, bullying, or a tank that is too bareTest the water and the temperature; watch for a bullying tankmate; check hiding places
Bloating / pinecone scalesSwollen belly, scales sticking out like a pineconeDropsy — fluid building up when organs fail; seriousVet, promptly — rarely fixable with water changes alone; quarantine the fish
Torn or rotting finsFrayed, ragged or shrinking fin edgesFin rot — bacteria taking hold after poor water, or fins nipped by a tankmateTest the water first; 25–30% water change; remove the nipper if there is one
Flashing / rubbing on objectsFish darting and scraping against decor or gravelSkin parasites or irritation — ammonia is a common irritantTest ammonia and nitrite first; if the water is clean and it continues, a vet identifies the parasite
Not eatingFish ignores food for more than a dayNew-tank stress, wrong food, cold water, or illness startingTest the water and temperature; try a small amount of a different food
Red / inflamed gillsGills look red or swollen, fast breathingAmmonia burn or gill parasitesTest ammonia and nitrite immediately — above 0 is an emergency: 30–50% water change now

Every row is the site's own entry, worded as "often linked to" — a description of the usual links, not a diagnosis.

FAQ

Why does every entry start with a water test?

Because the water is the most common cause and the easiest to rule out. Ammonia must read 0, nitrite must read 0, nitrate under 40 ppm. If any of those is off, fix the water first — whatever the symptom, the treatment will not work in dirty water.

Can one symptom diagnose my fish?

No. Symptoms overlap, and only a vet (or a lab test) can confirm what is actually wrong. The explorer tells you what a sign is often linked to and what to check first — that is information, not a diagnosis.

When is it an emergency?

Gasping at the surface, red gills with ammonia above 0, and bloating with pinecone scales are the three to act on now: water change immediately for the first two, a vet promptly for the third. A fish getting worse fast is also an emergency — ask a vet instead of waiting.

Should I medicate the main tank?

Not on a guess. Confirm the water first, and the diagnosis second — a vet or experienced keeper can confirm before you medicate. A sick fish goes to a quarantine tank where possible, so the main tank and its filter bacteria are not dosed for one fish.

My new fish is not eating — is it sick?

Probably not. A new fish skipping a day is normal — it needs time to settle. Test the water and temperature, try a small amount of a different food, and give it a day. A fish that has eaten for weeks and stops is worth watching closely.

How long do I watch clamped fins before doing something?

If the water is clean, give it a day — new fish often need time to settle. If it is still clamped and hiding after a day, look for a tankmate doing the chasing and check there are hiding places.

Where do I find a fish vet?

Ask a local aquarium shop — many know an aquatic veterinarian in the area. Take the water test numbers with you (ammonia, nitrite, nitrate, temperature): a vet starts from the water, just like this tool does.

Sources

  1. TheCycledTank species database — water targets ammonia 0, nitrite 0, nitrate under 40 ppm (Our recommendation).
  2. TheCycledTank symptom entries — the eight signs, their usual links and first checks, written as describe-don't-diagnose with vet referral (Our editorial entries).
  3. TheCycledTank Water Parameter Checker — the tool that tests the water first (Our tool).

Related tools