Enter your tank size, current nitrate and planned change and see the nitrate afterwards — plus the change size needed to reach your target. Know the change size before touching a bucket, and see whether tap nitrate is blocking progress. Everything runs in your browser; nothing is saved.
How it works
A water change dilutes what is in the tank towards what is in the tap. The nitrate left afterwards is:
Nitrate after = tap + (current − tap) × (1 − change fraction).
Take out half the water and half the gap to the tap reading disappears. The tap reading is the floor: if the tap reads 10 ppm, no change — not even a 100% one — can ever take the tank below 10 ppm.
The change size needed to reach a target in one change is the same idea turned around:
Change needed (%) = (current − target) ÷ (current − tap) × 100.
If the tap reading is already at or above the target, no water change can reach it — the tool says "Not reachable", and that is a tap-water problem, not a change-size problem. If the tank is already at or under the target, the answer is 0% — no change needed for nitrate, just the routine change.
The site's own targets are nitrate max 40 ppm, and 20 ppm for sensitive fish and shrimp. The routine baseline is a 25–30% weekly change. Anything over about 50% in one go is a big swing; two smaller changes days apart are gentler on the fish.
Worked example
A 20-gallon tank at 40 ppm nitrate, a 50% change, tap water at 0 ppm, target 20 ppm.
Tank 20 gal (actual water) · Current 40 ppm · Change 50% · Tap 0 ppm · Target 20 ppm.
After = 0 + (40 − 0) × (1 − 0.50). Needed = (40 − 20) ÷ (40 − 0) × 100. Water out = 50% × 20 gal.
After = 40 × 0.50 = 20 ppm. Water out = 10 gal (37.9 L). Needed = 20 ÷ 40 × 100 = 50%.
20 ppm nitrate after the change — and a 50% change is exactly what this case needs to reach 20 ppm.
Two more checks from the same formula. A 25% change instead: after = 40 × 0.75 = 30 ppm, and the change needed to reach 20 ppm is still 50%. Tap nitrate matters: a 10-gallon tank at 80 ppm, 50% change, tap at 10 ppm — after = 10 + (80 − 10) × 0.50 = 45 ppm, and the change needed to reach 20 ppm is (80 − 20) ÷ (80 − 10) × 100 = 85.7%.
How to read your results
The verdict word is the headline. "On target" means at or under 20 ppm — inside even the sensitive limit. "Above the sensitive limit" means under the 40 ppm general maximum but above 20 ppm — fine for hardy fish, not for sensitive fish and shrimp. "Still above the maximum" means over 40 ppm, and this change alone is not enough.
The stat grid gives the three numbers that decide the next step: nitrate after the change, the water out in gallons and litres, and the change needed to reach your target in one change. "Not reachable" means the tap water is already at or above the target. "0%" means the tank is already there.
What to do next: if the verdict is "Still above the maximum", repeat changes a few days apart rather than doing one huge one, and check what is producing the nitrate. If the tap is the blocker, a bigger change cannot fix it — test the tap, and check the test kit too.
Common mistakes
- Using the label gallons instead of the actual water in the tank. Substrate, rock and decor displace water, so the change is smaller than the sticker suggests — and so is the nitrate drop.
- Forgetting tap nitrate. A tap reading of 10 ppm caps every change at 10 ppm; blaming the tank misses the real cause.
- Doing one huge change instead of two smaller ones. Anything over about 50% in one go is a big swing; two changes days apart are gentler.
- Chasing 0 ppm. The targets are 20 ppm for sensitive fish and shrimp and 40 ppm maximum — 0 is not the goal.
- Assuming a change fixes the cause. A change dilutes nitrate; it does not stop whatever is producing it. If nitrate climbs back fast, look for the source — overfeeding, overstocking, or a filter that needs cleaning.
- Leaving the tap field blank when the tap has never been tested. Blank means 0 here; test the tap at least once so the floor is real.
What one change does
Nitrate after a single change, starting at 40 ppm with tap water at 0 ppm — and the change needed to reach 20 ppm from different starting points (tap 0 ppm).
| Change size | Nitrate after (from 40 ppm) | Starting nitrate | Change needed to reach 20 ppm |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10% | 36 ppm | 30 ppm | 33% |
| 25% | 30 ppm | 40 ppm | 50% |
| 30% | 28 ppm | 60 ppm | 67% |
| 50% | 20 ppm | 80 ppm | 75% |
| 75% | 10 ppm | — | — |
Read it as: a routine 25% weekly change on a 40 ppm tank lands at 30 ppm — still above the 20 ppm sensitive limit. Reaching 20 ppm from 40 ppm in one change takes 50%.
FAQ
Why didn't my nitrate drop as far as the calculator said?
The two usual causes are the ones the calculator warns about: the tank holds less water than its label size, so the change was smaller than planned — and the tap itself carries nitrate, which sets a floor no change can go below. Check both before doubting the test kit.
How big a change is too big?
Anything over about 50% in one go is a big swing for the fish. Two smaller changes days apart reach the same place more gently. The routine baseline is 25–30% weekly.
My tap reads 10 ppm — can I ever reach 20 ppm?
Yes, as long as the tap stays below the target. From 80 ppm with tap at 10 ppm, reaching 20 ppm takes an 85.7% change in one go — or several smaller ones. If the tap ever reads at or above the target, water changes alone cannot reach it.
Do I need to reach 0 ppm nitrate?
No. The site's targets are 20 ppm for sensitive fish and shrimp and 40 ppm maximum. A planted tank will often sit somewhere in between, and that is fine.
How often should I change water?
The routine baseline is a 25–30% change every week. That keeps nitrate in range on a normally stocked tank; a heavily stocked or overfed tank needs more, and the calculator shows how much more.
Why does the calculator say 0% needed?
The tank is already at or under the target, so no change is needed for nitrate. Keep the routine 25–30% weekly change anyway — it removes more than nitrate.
Sources
- Our data — TheCycledTank species database (data/species-db.json), water_targets. Nitrate max 40 ppm, 20 ppm for sensitive fish and shrimp; routine baseline 25–30% weekly. These are the site's own published water targets, and they are the numbers this tool is built on.
- Method — dilution arithmetic. After a partial change, what remains is the tap reading plus the unchanged fraction of the gap between the tank and the tap — the same volume-weighted mixing the RO Water Mixing Calculator runs. The 40 ppm and 20 ppm targets are the site's own, stated as such above.